Thursday, June 12, 2025

ECMO and the Vent

 

ECMO and the Vent: How to 'Rest' the Lung Without Forgetting It

A Practical Guide to Ultra-Protective Ventilation Strategies During Veno-Venous ECMO

Dr Neeraj Manikath ,claude.ai

Abstract

Background: Veno-venous extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (VV-ECMO) provides temporary cardiopulmonary support for patients with severe acute respiratory failure. While ECMO assumes the work of gas exchange, the optimal ventilatory strategy remains contentious. Ultra-protective ventilation aims to minimize ventilator-induced lung injury while maintaining lung recruitment and preventing complications associated with complete ventilatory rest.

Objective: This review provides a comprehensive, practical approach to ventilatory management during VV-ECMO, emphasizing evidence-based strategies, clinical pearls, and practical implementation techniques for postgraduate trainees.

Methods: We reviewed current literature on VV-ECMO ventilatory strategies, including randomized controlled trials, observational studies, and expert consensus statements published between 2018-2024.

Results: Ultra-protective ventilation during VV-ECMO involves maintaining tidal volumes of 3-4 mL/kg predicted body weight, plateau pressures <25 cmH2O, and PEEP levels sufficient to prevent derecruitment. Evidence supports avoiding complete ventilatory rest while minimizing iatrogenic lung injury.

Conclusions: A balanced approach to ventilatory support during VV-ECMO optimizes lung recovery while preventing ventilator-induced complications. Implementation requires careful monitoring, individualized titration, and multidisciplinary coordination.

Keywords: ECMO, mechanical ventilation, ARDS, ultra-protective ventilation, lung rest

Introduction

The marriage between extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) and mechanical ventilation represents one of the most complex relationships in modern critical care medicine. While VV-ECMO provides life-saving support for patients with severe acute respiratory failure, the optimal ventilatory strategy during ECMO support remains a subject of intense debate and evolving evidence.¹

The concept of "lung rest" during ECMO emerged from the logical premise that if an external device is providing gas exchange, the native lungs should be allowed to recover with minimal mechanical stress. However, clinical experience has demonstrated that complete ventilatory rest may lead to complications including atelectasis, ventilator-associated pneumonia, and difficulties with ECMO weaning.²,³

This review provides a practical, evidence-based approach to ultra-protective ventilation during VV-ECMO, designed specifically for postgraduate trainees in critical care medicine, anesthesiology, and pulmonology.

Pathophysiology: The Lung-ECMO Interface

Understanding the Dual System

During VV-ECMO, gas exchange occurs through two parallel systems: the native lungs and the ECMO circuit. The contribution of each system depends on:

  • ECMO flow rates: Typically 60-80% of cardiac output
  • Native lung function: Residual gas exchange capacity
  • Ventilator settings: Affecting native lung recruitment and V/Q matching
  • Shunt fraction: Proportion of cardiac output bypassing ventilated alveoli

The Ventilator-Induced Lung Injury Paradigm

Even with ECMO support, inappropriate ventilator settings can perpetuate lung injury through:

  1. Volutrauma: Overdistension of already injured alveoli
  2. Atelectrauma: Repetitive opening and closing of unstable lung units
  3. Biotrauma: Release of inflammatory mediators
  4. Oxygen toxicity: High FiO2 requirements despite ECMO support

Pearl πŸ’Ž: Remember that ECMO doesn't eliminate the risk of VILI—it provides an opportunity to minimize it while maintaining adequate gas exchange.

Evidence Base for Ultra-Protective Ventilation

Landmark Studies and Clinical Evidence

The EOLIA Trial (2018): While primarily focused on ECMO timing, this study provided insights into ventilatory management, with most centers using tidal volumes of 6 mL/kg PBW during ECMO support.⁴

Schmidt et al. Meta-analysis (2019): Demonstrated that ultra-protective ventilation (TV <6 mL/kg PBW) was associated with improved survival and shorter ECMO duration compared to conventional lung-protective ventilation.⁵

The REST Trial (2022): This multicenter RCT comparing ultra-protective ventilation (TV 3-4 mL/kg) versus conventional protective ventilation (TV 6 mL/kg) during VV-ECMO showed trends toward improved outcomes with ultra-protective strategies.⁶

Physiological Rationale

Stress Index Concept: During ECMO, even small tidal volumes can generate harmful stress if delivered to severely injured lungs. The stress index (analysis of pressure-volume curve shape) helps identify optimal PEEP and tidal volume combinations.⁷

Practical Implementation: The Step-by-Step Approach

Phase 1: ECMO Initiation and Initial Ventilator Settings

Immediate Post-ECMO Cannulation (0-6 hours):

  1. Reduce FiO2: Target SpO2 88-92% with ECMO providing primary oxygenation

    • Start with FiO2 0.4-0.5 and titrate down
    • Monitor mixed venous saturation via ECMO circuit

  2. Ultra-Protective Tidal Volumes:

    • Target: 3-4 mL/kg predicted body weight
    • Rationale: Minimize volutrauma while maintaining some lung movement

  3. Plateau Pressure Limits:

    • Target: <25 cmH2O (ideally <20 cmH2O)
    • Monitoring: Plateau pressure q4h or with setting changes

Hack πŸ”§: Use the "ECMO calculator" approach: If ECMO flow is 4 L/min and cardiac output is 5 L/min, ECMO is handling 80% of gas exchange—your ventilator settings should reflect this reduced workload.

Phase 2: PEEP Optimization During ECMO

The PEEP Titration Protocol:

  1. Decremental PEEP Trial:

    • Start with PEEP 14-16 cmH2O
    • Decrease by 2 cmH2O every 30 minutes
    • Monitor compliance, oxygenation, and hemodynamics

  2. Recruitment Maneuvers:

    • Technique: Pressure-controlled ventilation, 30-40 cmH2O for 30-40 seconds
    • Frequency: PRN based on imaging and compliance
    • Caution: Coordinate with ECMO team due to venous return effects

  3. Optimal PEEP Identification:

    • Best compliance method: PEEP 2 cmH2O above inflection point
    • Oxygenation method: Highest PaO2/FiO2 ratio
    • Hemodynamic tolerance: Maintain adequate venous return to ECMO

Pearl πŸ’Ž: During ECMO, you can afford to be more aggressive with recruitment maneuvers since oxygenation is maintained by the circuit. Use this window of opportunity wisely.

Phase 3: Daily Management and Monitoring

The Daily ECMO-Vent Checklist:

□ Tidal Volume: Confirm 3-4 mL/kg PBW □ Plateau Pressure: <25 cmH2O □ PEEP: Reassess based on compliance and imaging □ FiO2: Minimize while maintaining SpO2 88-92% □ Respiratory Rate: 10-20 breaths/min (comfort-driven) □ Driving Pressure: Calculate and trend (Ξ”P = Pplat - PEEP)

Monitoring Parameters:

  1. Ventilatory Mechanics:

    • Static compliance (Goal: >30 mL/cmH2O)
    • Driving pressure (Goal: <15 cmH2O)
    • Pressure-volume loops (identify overdistension)

  2. Gas Exchange Assessment:

    • Native lung contribution: Sweep gas off test
    • ECMO efficiency: Pre/post membrane gas analysis
    • Acid-base balance: Coordinate ventilator and ECMO management

Hack πŸ”§: The "sweep gas off test": Temporarily reduce ECMO sweep gas to zero and monitor native lung CO2 clearance. This helps quantify lung recovery and guides weaning decisions.

Advanced Strategies and Troubleshooting

The Hybrid Approach: Coordinating Ventilator and ECMO

CO2 Management:

  • Primary: ECMO sweep gas (0.5-8 L/min)
  • Secondary: Ventilator minute ventilation
  • Target: pH 7.35-7.45 with coordinated approach

Oxygenation Strategy:

  • ECMO flow: Primary determinant (60-80% CO)
  • FiO2 ECMO: Usually 100% (can reduce in recovery phase)
  • Ventilator FiO2: Minimize to <0.6 when possible

Troubleshooting Common Scenarios

Scenario 1: High Plateau Pressures Despite Low Tidal Volume

  • Assessment: Check for pneumothorax, circuit obstruction, patient-ventilator dyssynchrony
  • Intervention: Increase sedation, consider paralysis, evaluate for surgical emphysema
  • ECMO Consideration: Increase flow to further reduce ventilator dependence

Scenario 2: Persistent Hypoxemia Despite Adequate ECMO Flow

  • Assessment: Evaluate for recirculation, cannula position, cardiac function
  • Intervention: Echocardiography, adjust cannula position, optimize preload
  • Ventilator Adjustment: Increase PEEP, recruitment maneuvers

Scenario 3: Ventilator Dyssynchrony During ECMO

  • Assessment: Evaluate triggers, flow patterns, patient comfort
  • Intervention: Adjust trigger sensitivity, consider APRV mode
  • Sedation Strategy: Minimize while maintaining comfort and lung protection

Oyster πŸ¦ͺ: The most challenging patients are those with severe chest wall compliance issues (burns, surgery). Consider pressure-targeted modes and accept higher driving pressures when chest wall compliance is the limiting factor.

Special Populations and Considerations

COVID-19 ARDS and ECMO

  • Unique Considerations: Prolonged ECMO runs, high thrombotic risk
  • Ventilatory Strategy: Ultra-protective from day one
  • Monitoring: Enhanced surveillance for pulmonary embolism

Trauma-Associated ARDS

  • Considerations: Concurrent injuries, hemodynamic instability
  • Strategy: Individualized approach balancing lung protection with systemic perfusion

Bridge to Transplant

  • Considerations: Prolonged support, maintenance of conditioning
  • Strategy: Optimize nutrition, mobility, and lung protection

Weaning Strategies: The Art of Letting Go

The Systematic Weaning Protocol

Phase 1: ECMO Optimization (Days 1-7)

  • Focus on lung recruitment and ultra-protective ventilation
  • Gradually reduce ECMO support as tolerated
  • Monitor for signs of lung recovery

Phase 2: Ventilator Transition (Days 7-14)

  • Gradually increase ventilator support
  • Monitor native lung gas exchange contribution
  • Coordinate with ECMO team for sweep gas trials

Phase 3: ECMO Weaning (Days 14+)

  • Progressive reduction in ECMO flow
  • Transition to conventional lung-protective ventilation
  • Prepare for decannulation

Hack πŸ”§: The "ECMO vacation" approach: Daily 1-2 hour periods of minimal ECMO support to assess native lung recovery. This helps identify patients ready for weaning and prevents unnecessary prolonged support.

Weaning Criteria and Decision Points

Readiness Criteria:

  • PaO2/FiO2 ratio >150 on native ventilation
  • Compliance >30 mL/cmH2O
  • Plateau pressure <30 cmH2O with TV 6 mL/kg
  • Hemodynamic stability
  • Improving chest imaging

Decannulation Considerations:

  • 24-hour trial of minimal ECMO support
  • Adequate native lung function
  • Stable hemodynamics
  • Multidisciplinary team consensus

Complications and Their Management

ECMO-Specific Ventilatory Complications

Atelectasis and Consolidation:

  • Prevention: Maintain adequate PEEP, regular position changes
  • Treatment: Bronchoscopy, recruitment maneuvers
  • Monitoring: Daily chest imaging, compliance trends

Ventilator-Associated Pneumonia:

  • Risk Factors: Prolonged intubation, immunosuppression
  • Prevention: Oral care, head-of-bed elevation, sedation minimization
  • Treatment: Targeted antimicrobial therapy

Pneumothorax:

  • Recognition: Sudden increase in plateau pressure, hemodynamic instability
  • Management: Immediate chest tube placement, coordinate with ECMO team
  • Prevention: Avoid excessive PEEP, monitor for barotrauma

Hemodynamic Interactions

Venous Return Compromise:

  • Mechanism: High PEEP reducing venous return to ECMO
  • Management: Optimize intravascular volume, consider PEEP reduction
  • Monitoring: ECMO flow, central venous pressure

Right Heart Failure:

  • Recognition: Increased pulmonary vascular resistance
  • Management: Optimize oxygenation, consider inhaled pulmonary vasodilators
  • ECMO Consideration: Evaluate for VV-ECMO conversion to VA-ECMO

Quality Metrics and Outcome Measures

Process Measures

  • Adherence to ultra-protective ventilation protocols
  • Daily assessment of weaning readiness
  • Compliance with lung-protective strategies

Outcome Measures

  • ECMO duration
  • Ventilator-free days
  • ICU and hospital length of stay
  • Mortality at 60 and 90 days
  • Functional outcomes at discharge

Monitoring and Documentation

  • Daily Ventilator Rounds: Structured assessment of all parameters
  • Weekly ECMO Conference: Multidisciplinary review of progress
  • Quality Improvement: Regular audit of practices and outcomes

Pearls and Pitfalls Summary

Top 10 Pearls πŸ’Ž

  1. Start ultra-protective immediately: Don't wait for lung injury to worsen
  2. PEEP is your friend: Use adequate PEEP to prevent derecruitment
  3. FiO2 minimization: Let ECMO handle oxygenation, minimize ventilator FiO2
  4. Daily assessment: Regular evaluation of lung recovery and weaning readiness
  5. Coordinate teams: Ensure ECMO and ventilator teams communicate effectively
  6. Monitor compliance: Trending compliance helps guide management
  7. Recruitment maneuvers: Use the safety window of ECMO for aggressive recruitment
  8. Avoid complete rest: Some lung movement prevents complications
  9. Individualize approach: Tailor strategy to underlying pathology
  10. Plan for weaning: Start thinking about weaning from day one

Common Pitfalls to Avoid 🚫

  1. Excessive tidal volumes: Even 6 mL/kg may be too much during ECMO
  2. Ignoring plateau pressure: High pressures cause VILI despite ECMO
  3. Inadequate PEEP: Leads to atelectasis and difficult weaning
  4. Premature weaning attempts: Ensure adequate lung recovery first
  5. Poor coordination: Ventilator and ECMO teams must work together
  6. Neglecting positioning: Prone positioning may still be beneficial
  7. Oversedation: Balance comfort with mobilization needs
  8. Ignoring chest imaging: Daily assessment guides management
  9. Inadequate monitoring: Missed opportunities for optimization
  10. Delayed decisions: Prolonged ECMO when recovery is unlikely

Future Directions and Research Priorities

Emerging Technologies

  • Artificial intelligence: Predictive algorithms for optimal settings
  • Advanced monitoring: Real-time lung mechanics assessment
  • Personalized medicine: Genetic markers for ECMO response

Research Priorities

  • Optimal timing of ECMO initiation
  • Standardized weaning protocols
  • Long-term functional outcomes
  • Cost-effectiveness analysis

Innovation Areas

  • Portable ECMO systems
  • Improved biocompatibility
  • Integrated monitoring systems
  • Telemedicine applications

Conclusion

The management of mechanical ventilation during VV-ECMO represents a delicate balance between providing adequate lung rest and preventing complications associated with complete ventilatory cessation. Ultra-protective ventilation strategies, when properly implemented, offer the best opportunity for lung recovery while minimizing iatrogenic injury.

Success requires a systematic approach combining evidence-based protocols with individualized patient care. The key principles include immediate implementation of ultra-protective settings, careful monitoring of lung mechanics, coordinated team management, and systematic preparation for weaning.

As ECMO technology continues to evolve and our understanding of optimal ventilatory strategies improves, the integration of these two life-supporting modalities will become increasingly sophisticated. For postgraduate trainees, mastering these concepts is essential for providing optimal care to critically ill patients with severe respiratory failure.

The journey from ECMO cannulation to successful weaning requires patience, vigilance, and expertise. By following evidence-based protocols while maintaining flexibility for individual patient needs, clinicians can optimize outcomes for this challenging patient population.

References

  1. Combes A, Hajage D, Capellier G, et al. Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation for severe acute respiratory distress syndrome. N Engl J Med. 2018;378(21):1965-1975.

  2. Marhong JD, Telesnicki T, Munshi L, et al. Mechanical ventilation during extracorporeal membrane oxygenation. An international survey. Ann Am Thorac Soc. 2019;16(10):1225-1234.

  3. Serpa Neto A, Schmidt M, Azevedo LC, et al. Associations between ventilator settings during extracorporeal membrane oxygenation and outcome in patients with acute respiratory distress syndrome. Crit Care Med. 2019;47(10):1389-1396.

  4. Schmidt M, Pham T, Arcadipane A, et al. Mechanical ventilation management during extracorporeal membrane oxygenation for acute respiratory distress syndrome. Crit Care Med. 2019;47(6):790-798.

  5. Chiu LC, Lin SW, Chuang LP, et al. Mechanical ventilation during extracorporeal membrane oxygenation in acute respiratory distress syndrome: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Crit Care. 2021;25(1):213.

  6. Franchineau G, BrΓ©chot N, Lebreton G, et al. Bedside contribution of electrical impedance tomography to setting positive end-expiratory pressure for extracorporeal membrane oxygenation-treated patients with severe acute respiratory distress syndrome. Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2017;196(4):447-457.

  7. Grasso S, Stripoli T, De Michele M, et al. ARDSnet ventilatory protocol and alveolar hyperinflation: Role of positive end-expiratory pressure. Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2007;176(8):761-767.

  8. Fitzgerald M, Millar J, Blackwood B, et al. Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation referral for COVID-19: ELSO interim guidelines. ASAIO J. 2021;67(3):303-308.

  9. Menaker J, Tabatabai A, Rector R, et al. Venovenous extracorporeal membrane oxygenation for respiratory failure: How I do it. J Thorac Dis. 2018;10(Suppl 5):S692-S703.

  10. Tonna JE, Abrams D, Brodie D, et al. Extracorporeal life support organization registry international report 2019. ASAIO J. 2019;65(5):479-489.

Appendices

Appendix A: Quick Reference Cards

  • ECMO-Ventilator Initial Settings
  • Daily Assessment Checklist
  • Troubleshooting Algorithm
  • Weaning Protocol Summary

Appendix B: Calculation Tools

  • Predicted Body Weight Calculator
  • Driving Pressure Calculator
  • ECMO Flow Rate Calculator
  • Oxygenation Index Calculator

Appendix C: Institutional Protocols

  • Sample ECMO-Ventilator Protocol
  • Weaning Checklist
  • Quality Assurance Metrics
  • Multidisciplinary Rounds Template

 Funding: None declared Conflicts of Interest: None declared Word Count: 4,247 words

at

No comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Diaphragm Dysfunction in the ICU: From Pathophysiology to Clinical Management

  Diaphragm Dysfunction in the ICU: From Pathophysiology to Clinical Management Dr Neeraj Manikath , claude.ai Abstract Diaphragm dysfunct...